RR
“I used to audit S corps for the IRS. The owners who got hit hardest weren't greedy — they just picked a salary out of thin air. So this tool does it the way I did it at the IRS: it prices each job you actually do, shows you the savings and the risk side by side, and hands you the paper to prove it.”
This is an educational estimate, not tax advice and not a salary recommendation. The numbers it shows are not a reasonable compensation determination by Romeo Razi, CPA, IRS Resolution Service or anyone else. Using it does not create a CPA–client relationship.
What counts as a reasonable salary depends on facts this tool doesn't know: your exact duties, your market, your industry, your history and more. Don't set your salary from this page alone. Review your numbers with your own CPA, enrolled agent or tax attorney before you act.
Nothing you type leaves your browser.
An IRS examiner doesn't pick a percentage. They ask what it would cost to hire people to do each job you do. So do that.
Drag the slider or tap the chart. Lower salary = more savings on paper, but more audit risk.
The salary is half the battle. How you pay it is the other half.
RREstimate, not tax advice. 2026 rates: Social Security 6.2% each side up to $184,500; Medicare 1.45% each side plus 0.9% above $200,000 single / $250,000 joint; FUTA $42; 20% QBI deduction on business profit. Doesn't model QBI limits above $201,750 single / $403,550 joint, state taxes, retirement contributions or health insurance. Wage rates are BLS national medians — edit any rate to match your market.
If you own an S corp and work in it, the law treats you as an employee. You have to pay yourself a W-2 salary — with Social Security and Medicare taken out — before you take the rest out as distributions, which skip those taxes. That's the whole S corp tax break, and it's why the IRS watches the salary number so closely.
There's no percentage in the tax code. The test is simple to say and hard to fake: what would you have to pay someone else to do your job? The IRS lists what courts look at (Fact Sheet FS-2008-25):
RRThe "60/40 rule" you'll see online isn't in any law or IRS guidance. I never once used a percentage in an audit. I asked what the job was worth. Write down how you got your number — job ads, a wage survey, what you'd pay a manager — and keep it in your files. That one page is your defense.
Every case below is a real owner, a real salary and a real ruling. Click through to read each one. The pattern is the same for 35 years: if you work in the business, the money you take out for that work is wages, whatever you call it.
| Case | Owner | Salary paid | Taken out | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Radtke (1990) | Lawyer | $0 | $18,225 | All of it was wages |
| Spicer (1990) | Accountant | $0 | Dividends | Wages |
| Watson (2012) | CPA | $24,000 | $203,651 | Court set $91,044 |
| McAlary (2013) | Real estate broker | $0 | $240,000 | Court set $83,200 |
| Glass Blocks (2013) | Manufacturer | $0 | $30,000+/yr | Wages, plus penalties |
| Fleischer (2016) | Financial advisor | ~$35,000/yr | $274,893 (3 yrs) | Owed $41,563 SE tax |
David E. Watson, P.C. v. United States. An experienced CPA working full time at a firm with close to $3 million in revenue paid himself a $24,000 salary in 2002 and 2003 while taking $203,651 and $175,470 in distributions. The government's expert said a reasonable salary was $91,044. The court agreed, and the extra $67,044 a year became subject to Social Security and Medicare tax, plus penalties and interest.
Sean McAlary Ltd. v. Commissioner (T.C. Summary Opinion 2013-62). The owner ran the whole brokerage and was its top salesperson. His salary was set at $24,000 but never actually paid, and he took $240,000 in distributions. The IRS's expert argued for about $100,000. The court set it at $83,200 and assessed payroll tax on that amount.
Glass Blocks Unlimited v. Commissioner (T.C. Memo. 2013-180). The president was the company's only full-time worker and made every decision. He took no salary; money moved to him as distributions and undocumented “loans.” The court treated more than $30,000 in each of 2007 and 2008 as wages — even though the company's taxable income was well below that — and upheld failure-to-file and failure-to-deposit penalties.
Fleischer v. Commissioner (T.C. Memo. 2016-238). Ryan Fleischer, an independent broker and insurance agent, paid himself about $35,000 a year from his S corp and took $274,893 out as distributions over 2009–2011. The problem: his brokerage and insurance contracts were in his own name, not the corporation's. The court said the commissions were his personal self-employment income and upheld a $41,563 tax bill. If you're licensed personally — broker, insurance agent, some advisors — the contract has to be with your S corp.
Source: Kitces.com
Joseph Radtke, S.C. v. United States, 895 F.2d 1196. Radtke was his law firm's only full-time lawyer. In 1982 he took no salary and paid himself $18,225 as dividends. The court held that all of it was wages subject to payroll tax, because it was really payment for his legal work.
Source: Justia (full opinion)
Spicer Accounting, Inc. v. United States, 918 F.2d 90. The firm's only accountant took dividends instead of a salary and argued he was volunteering his services. The court said what matters is whether the money was paid for work, not what it's called — and treated it as wages.
Source: Leagle (full opinion)
RRLook at the dates — 1990, 2012, 2013, 2016. The rule hasn't changed in 35 years, and the IRS keeps winning with the same argument. None of these owners kept their low number, and every one of them paid lawyers or experts to fight about it. Writing down a defensible salary up front costs a fraction of that.
The opposite problem exists too: in Clary Hood, Inc. v. Commissioner (T.C. Memo. 2022-15, aff'd 4th Cir. 2023) a C corporation's $5 million bonus to its CEO was partly disallowed as too high. That's rarely an issue for S corps, where the IRS's concern is salaries that are too low. The Tax Adviser, Oct. 2024
Ruadhri McCormick, owner of Single Shot on Capitol Hill, withheld Social Security, Medicare and income tax from up to 87 employees' paychecks from 2014 to 2024 and kept it. Prosecutors say he spent nearly $400,000 on a Vashon Island home, $125,000 at casinos and $38,000 on travel. He also didn't file personal returns for 2015–2024. Restitution: $1,446,341.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice
Ephantus Mwangi withheld $331,404 in employee taxes at True Payment Solutions and True POS Solutions and never sent it in, while moving more than $1.5 million from the companies to his personal accounts for luxury cars, a rented mansion and casino trips. Restitution: $1,597,835.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice
Up from $184,500 in 2026. Salary up to that amount carries 12.4% Social Security tax (split between you and your S corp); above it, only Medicare. For most owners using this calculator, the change adds a few hundred dollars at most — but if your salary is near the cap, 2027 payroll will cost slightly more.
Source: Journal of Accountancy
The IRS's examination and collection workforce dropped from 27,217 at the end of fiscal 2024 to 19,612 a year later, and the Inflation Reduction Act enforcement money ran out on December 31, 2025. Revenue from audits fell 35% in fiscal 2025.
Sources: TIGTA report 2026-3S0-045 · Journal of Accountancy
TIGTA found single-owner S corporations with over $100,000 of profit that reported no officer pay while taking $69 billion in distributions — an estimated $25 billion in missing wages and $3.3 billion in Social Security and Medicare tax. Fewer than 1% of S corps were examined for it, which is why the IRS is under pressure to look harder.
Source: TIGTA report 2021-30-042 · Accounting Today
RRFewer IRS agents doesn't mean nobody's looking. A $0 salary next to big distributions shows up on the face of the return — no agent has to dig for it. And the two October sentences are a different, worse problem: once you withhold tax from a paycheck, that money isn't yours. Pay yourself on payroll, and send in every dollar you withhold.
An S corp salary has to go through real payroll: withholding, quarterly Form 941, a W-2 in January. The taxes withheld from your own paycheck are "trust fund" money — if the business doesn't send them in, the IRS can bill you personally (§ 6672). And if you get a penalty notice, the IRS has to follow its own rules too.
YB“We had a $14 million payroll tax case. To assess the trust fund penalty, the IRS manager has to sign off first. We did a FOIA request and found the penalty was assessed in December but the manager's signature was in April — four months later. We requested abatement on close to $2 million. The fact that the IRS tells you something doesn't mean it's always right.”
▶ From the IRS Insider Interview — watch on YouTube
RRPay yourself on a schedule — monthly or every two weeks — not one big check in December. A steady paycheck looks like a real salary, because it is one.
Romeo audited employment taxes from inside the IRS. He'll set your S corp salary, document how he got there, and tell you what you'll save.
Get a Free Consultation