⚖ The Kwong Decision — COVID Penalty Refunds

The IRS may owe you back the penalties it charged you during COVID. Here's how to claim yours.

The short answer: A November 2025 court decision (Kwong v. United States) read the tax code to say that filing and payment deadlines were automatically postponed for the entire COVID federal disaster period — January 20, 2020 through July 10, 2023. If that reading holds, late-filing and late-payment penalties (and related interest) assessed for that 3.5-year window should never have been charged. The National Taxpayer Advocate says tens of millions of taxpayers may be affected — but you generally must file a claim (Form 843) to get anything back. Nothing is automatic.

⏰ General claim deadline: July 10, 2026 — but many taxpayers still have time after that date. Check your situation below.
Quick Facts — Kwong COVID Penalty Refunds
Tens of Millions
of taxpayers were assessed penalties or interest for returns and payments due Jan 20, 2020 – Jul 10, 2023
Filed or paid "late" in 2020–2023
Penalties + interest assessed
Kwong: deadlines were postponed
✓ File a claim to preserve your refund
"When relief exists but is difficult to access, taxpayers — especially those without representation — are at risk of losing benefits... this situation may well produce dramatically different outcomes for the 'well advised' versus the 'unaware.'"
— Erin Collins, National Taxpayer Advocate, April 2026

What the Kwong decision actually said

The case turns on one provision: IRC § 7508A(d), the "mandatory postponement" rule Congress added for federally declared disasters. As it existed when COVID was declared, it automatically postpones filing and payment deadlines for the period a federal disaster declaration is in effect, plus 60 days.

Nobody expected a disaster declaration to last 3.5 years. But COVID's did: January 20, 2020 through May 11, 2023. Add 60 days and you land on July 10, 2023.

In Kwong v. United States, 179 Fed. Cl. 382 (Nov. 2025), the Court of Federal Claims held that "the plain meaning of that statute is that the automatic extension runs from the beginning of the disaster declaration, through the end of the declared disaster period, and until 60 days after the end of the declared disaster period." Under that logic, returns and payments due anywhere inside that window were not legally late until after July 10, 2023 — which means the IRS should not have assessed failure-to-file, failure-to-pay, or estimated-tax penalties for that period, nor charged interest on those amounts.

Important — The Law Is Not Settled

The government disagrees with this reading and the Department of Justice is expected to appeal. Final resolution could take years. Filing a claim does not guarantee a refund — it preserves your right to one if the taxpayer-favorable reading holds. But if you never file and the decision is upheld, the statute of limitations will generally bar you from ever collecting. That asymmetry — small cost to file, total loss if you don't — is why the National Taxpayer Advocate publicly urged taxpayers to act.

The timeline that created the refund window

Who is potentially affected

This is not a niche issue for a special class of taxpayer. Per the Taxpayer Advocate Service, the affected population spans individuals, small businesses, large corporations, estates, and trusts, across income, employment, estate, gift, and excise taxes. If any of these describe you, it's worth pulling transcripts:

Situation (2020–2023)Potentially Affected?What to Look For
Filed a 2019–2022 return lateYESFailure-to-file penalty (up to 25% of tax due) assessed for returns due Jan 2020 – Jul 2023.
Paid a balance lateYESFailure-to-pay penalty plus interest that began accruing during the disaster window.
Missed estimated tax paymentsYESEstimated tax penalties for quarters due inside the window.
Business payroll deposits lateYESFailure-to-deposit penalties on 941-series obligations due in the window.
Late international information returnsYESForms like 5471/3520 carry five-figure penalties even when no tax is due — explicitly flagged by the Taxpayer Advocate.
Debt pre-dates 2020, but interest/penalties kept accruing during COVIDUNSETTLEDThe IRS says no windfall for pre-disaster delinquencies; Kwong didn't decide it. A protective claim preserves the argument cheaply.
Penalties for returns due after July 10, 2023NOOutside the postponement window. (But check the new AEP automatic relief and standard penalty abatement instead.)
Romeo Razi, CPA — Former IRS Auditor

"Inside the IRS, penalty assessments are automated — the computer assessed failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties on 2019, 2020, and 2021 returns by the millions without any human ever asking whether a disaster postponement applied. That's why this is so widespread. The system did exactly what it was programmed to do, and a court has now said the programming may have been wrong for three and a half years."

Step 1: Find out what you actually paid — pull your transcripts

Before filing anything, know your numbers. Your IRS account transcripts for tax years 2019 through 2022 show every penalty and interest charge, with dates. You can pull them free in minutes through your IRS Online Account.

What to look for on the transcript:

If you have multiple years, business accounts, or a Revenue Officer involved, a tax professional with a power of attorney can pull every year and every module at once and total the exposure in one pass.

Step 2: File Form 843 — and make it a protective claim

Refunds and abatements in this situation are claimed on Form 843, Claim for Refund and Request for Abatement — one form per tax period. Because the legal issue is still being litigated, the Taxpayer Advocate's guidance is to file it as a protective claim:

  1. Complete a Form 843 for each tax year/period where COVID-window penalties or interest were assessed. You don't need to compute an exact refund amount for a protective claim — but include as much detail as you can.
  2. Write "Protective Refund Claim Pursuant to Kwong Case" (or similar) across the top of the form, per the Taxpayer Advocate's direction and IRM 25.6.1 protective-claim rules. Identify the contingency — the pending Kwong litigation over IRC § 7508A(d) — and the specific years.
  3. Mail it on paper. Form 843 cannot be e-filed. This is the single biggest practical trap in the whole process.
  4. Send it certified mail, return receipt requested. Under the timely-mailing-is-timely-filing rule (IRC § 7502), your postmark date is your filing date — and certified mail is your proof if the IRS misplaces a paper claim. Keep copies of everything.
  5. Then wait — possibly years. The IRS typically holds protective claims in suspense until the courts resolve the issue, then the claim is "perfected" with final numbers. Filing now simply stops your limitations period from expiring while everyone waits.
Also Available: Abatement of Unpaid Penalties

Claims aren't only for money you already paid. If COVID-window penalties are sitting assessed but unpaid on your account — for example, baked into the balance you're paying down on an installment agreement — you can file a protective claim for abatement of those amounts too. If Kwong holds, they'd come off the balance.

Missed July 10, 2026? You may not be out of time

July 10, 2026 was the general "most taxpayers" date — it was never a single universal statutory deadline. Your personal deadline under IRC § 6511 is the later of:

That means claims can still be timely after July 10, 2026 for people who paid COVID-era penalties within the last two years — including through installment agreement payments, levies, and refund offsets — for people who filed the underlying returns late, and for people with open audits, appeals, or litigation. We built a dedicated guide for exactly this: Missed the July 10 Kwong deadline? Here's who still has time — and what to do this week.

Kwong vs. the new Automatic Penalty Relief (AEP) — don't confuse them

Two days before the Kwong deadline, on July 8, 2026, the IRS announced its new Automatic Exemption from Penalty (AEP) program. They are completely different animals, and you can potentially benefit from both:

Kwong Refund ClaimsAEP (Automatic Penalty Relief)
DirectionBackward-looking — refunds/abatement of 2020–2023 penaltiesForward-looking — prevents new penalties from being assessed
Action requiredYou must file Form 843 (paper, mailed)None — applied automatically at processing
Who qualifiesAnyone assessed penalties/interest for the disaster windowTaxpayers with 3 years (or 12 quarters) of clean compliance history
CertaintyContingent on litigation outcomeAnnounced IRS policy, rolling out summer 2026

Frequently asked questions

What is the Kwong decision, in one sentence?
A federal court held that the tax code automatically postponed filing and payment deadlines for the entire COVID disaster period (Jan 20, 2020 – Jul 10, 2023), which — if upheld — means late-filing and late-payment penalties and related interest assessed for that window shouldn't have been charged.
Is this real, or another "IRS fresh start" gimmick?
It's real — the source is the National Taxpayer Advocate (an independent office inside the IRS), who publicly urged taxpayers to file claims before July 10, 2026. But it is also genuinely uncertain: the government disputes the ruling and an appeal is expected. Anyone who guarantees you a refund is misleading you. What's certain is the procedure: a timely claim preserves your rights; no claim means no refund even if taxpayers win.
How much money could this be worth?
It depends entirely on your account. The failure-to-file penalty alone runs 5% per month up to 25% of the unpaid tax; failure-to-pay adds 0.5% per month; interest compounds on top. Someone who filed a 2019 or 2020 return a year late with a $20,000 balance could easily have $5,000–$7,000+ in COVID-window penalties and interest at stake. Your account transcripts give the exact figures.
Was July 10, 2026 the deadline for everyone?
No. It was the conservative "most taxpayers" date. The real limitations rule (IRC § 6511) is 3 years from filing or 2 years from payment, whichever is later — so recent payments, late-filed returns, and open exams/appeals can keep the window open. See our missed-deadline guide.
Can I e-file Form 843?
No. Form 843 is paper-only, which the Taxpayer Advocate has called out as a real burden. Mail it certified with return receipt — the postmark is your proof of timely filing under IRC § 7502.
I'm on an installment agreement that includes COVID-era penalties. Does this affect me?
Potentially in two ways: payments you made in the last two years that were applied to COVID-window penalties may support a still-timely refund claim, and penalties assessed but not yet paid can be the subject of a protective abatement claim. If Kwong holds, your remaining balance could shrink. This intersects with how your agreement is structured — worth a professional look.
Does this apply to state tax penalties?
No. Kwong interprets a federal statute (IRC § 7508A) and applies to federal penalties and interest only. States have their own rules and their own COVID relief programs, which are separate.
What if I already received First Time Abate or reasonable-cause relief for one of these years?
Then part of your penalty exposure may already be resolved — but interest, other periods, and other penalty types may remain. It also raises a strategic question: if Kwong ultimately wipes a penalty by operation of law, relief you "spent" on that year might have been usable elsewhere. This is exactly the kind of multi-year cleanup where a professional review pays for itself.
Romeo Razi, CPA
Former IRS Tax Examiner (Individual & Employment Tax Division) · CPA · 15+ years in private practice
Romeo spent years auditing businesses inside the IRS before switching sides. He's helped clients resolve IRS debts ranging from a few thousand dollars to $440,000. He founded Taxed Right LLC to give everyone access to insider IRS knowledge.

Want to know what the IRS charged you during COVID —
and whether a claim is worth filing?

We'll pull your transcripts, total the COVID-window penalties and interest on your account, tell you honestly whether your claim window is open, and file the protective claims correctly (certified, documented, one per period). Flat-fee review by a team that includes a former IRS auditor. No refund guarantees — anyone promising those is lying to you. Just the numbers and the correct procedure.

Get a Free Transcript Review →